What’s the first thing that comes to mind when you think of food on a Florida Keys vacation? Fresh seafood, of course! In this guide, we’re uncovering Marathon’s most iconic seafood spots—perfect for savoring the catch of the day while soaking in the Florida Keys vibes.
And after a beautiful sunset and wonderful meal, you’ll want a convenient and cozy place to stay. Check out Hip-Stays.com options for rentals in Marathon to make the most of your vacation. Let’s uncover some of the best seafood spots in Marathon to enjoy a dinner out in this beautiful island town.
1. Best Surf-and-Turf: FL Keys Steak and Lobster House
Looking for the perfect surf-and-turf experience? Look no further than FL Keys Steak and Lobster House. A staple in Marathon, this cozy spot offers a variety of fresh seafood options paired perfectly with succulent steaks. The lobster tail is a standout, but don’t overlook their seafood platters that feature everything from shrimp to crab cakes. For something a little different, their lobster bisque is a must-try! It’s rich, creamy, and packed with that unmistakable lobster flavor.
Pro Tip: Whether you’re in the mood for seafood, steak, or a combination of both, FL Keys Steak and Lobster House delivers a top-notch dining experience with friendly service and a relaxed atmosphere. It’s one of the most sought-after restaurants in Marathon, so be sure to make reservations in advance!
2. Variety Galore: Florida Keys Seafood Grill
When it comes to variety, Florida Keys Seafood Grill offers a little bit of everything. From grilled mahi-mahi to freshly shucked oysters, this spot delivers a wide range of fresh seafood that’s sure to please any palate. The Key lime pie here is the perfect way to end your meal, hitting that ideal blend of tart and sweet.
Bonus: They also serve up an amazing lobster bisque, perfect for warming you up after a day of exploring the Keys.
3. Catch and Cook: Lazy Days South
For stunning waterfront views and mouthwatering seafood, Lazy Days South is a can’t-miss destination. Their “Catch and Cook” option lets you bring in your freshly caught fish, and their chefs will prepare it just the way you like it—blackened, grilled, fried, or sautéed. Pair it with a side of their creamy mashed potatoes or tropical mango salsa for a flavor explosion you’ll be raving about long after your visit.
Must-Try: Don’t leave without trying their fried conch fritters or their signature shrimp scampi. Both are crowd-pleasers that locals and visitors rave about.
4. Laid-Back Dining: Island Fish Company
Island Fish Company is the place to be if you’re looking for a laid-back vibe with unforgettable food. Located right on the water, this restaurant is perfect for sunset dining with a cocktail in hand. Their menu boasts a variety of fresh seafood dishes, from coconut shrimp to grilled grouper sandwiches. Oh, and their seafood nachos? Absolutely legendary.
Insider Scoop: Happy hour here is a must! Sip on a frozen Key lime colada while enjoying discounted appetizers and the cool ocean breeze.
5. Sushi and More: Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar
For something a little different, head to Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar. This Marathon gem serves up not only fresh seafood but also an impressive selection of sushi. Whether you’re craving a spicy tuna roll or a plate of Florida lobster, Castaway has you covered.
Highlight: Their “Marathon Marina Sushi Roll” is a showstopper, combining local seafood with fresh ingredients to create a one-of-a-kind culinary experience.
6. Local Favorite: Keys Fisheries Market & Marina
A local favorite, Keys Fisheries Market & Marina offers some of the freshest seafood in Marathon. Famous for their lobster Reuben sandwich, this casual spot is perfect for enjoying a meal with stunning waterfront views. From stone crab claws to their daily fresh catch, everything here is guaranteed to delight seafood lovers.
Pro Tip: Stop by their fish market to pick up some fresh seafood to cook back at your vacation rental—it doesn’t get fresher than this!
7. Market Meets Eatery: Brutus Seafood Market & Eatery
Brutus Seafood Market & Eatery is the ultimate spot for those who want a mix of fresh seafood and laid-back vibes. Part restaurant, part market, Brutus serves up everything from shrimp tacos to conch ceviche. Their outdoor seating area is a great spot to enjoy your meal while soaking in the Florida Keys sunshine.
Must-Try: Their blackened fish sandwich is a hit, and don’t forget to grab some fresh seafood from the market on your way out.
8. Waterfront Casual: Burdines Waterfront |
|
|
Known more for its burgers and fries, Burdines Waterfront does offer a few seafood options that locals love. Their fried fish sandwich and fresh catch of the day are worth checking out if you’re looking for a casual meal with beautiful waterfront views. Insider Note: Pair your meal with their famous Key lime pie for the perfect sweet ending. |
Marathon is a seafood lover’s paradise, packed with fresh flavors, unbeatable views, and local charm. From surf-and-turf feasts to quick bites at food trucks, these spots promise a true taste of the Florida Keys. Whether you’re in the mood for a fancy surf-and-turf dinner or a casual waterside bite, these restaurants deliver on flavor, atmosphere, and fresh-from-the-ocean goodness.
Ready to plan your foodie adventure? Book your Florida Keys getaway with Hip Stays today and indulge in Marathon’s vibrant seafood scene—the ultimate foodie adventure awaits! Bon appétit!
Seafood Paradise Awaits!
Whether you’re in the mood for a casual fish sandwich, a lobster feast, or sushi with a Florida Keys twist, Marathon’s seafood scene has something for every taste. So next time you’re staying at Hip Stays, make sure to add some of these local gems to your list. Trust us, your taste buds will thank you!
P.S. At Hip Stays, we know that great food is key (pun intended!) to a memorable getaway. Book your stay at Reel Hip, our stylish vacation rental, and enjoy a seafood feast from the comfort of your private patio. Or dive into our quaint little island town and let Marathon’s best restaurants do the cooking for you.